Diseases That Mimic MS
By: Chris Ratliff and reviewed by Jack Burks M.D.
It is hardly unusual to hear stories of people who have been
misdiagnosed several times before finally being diagnosed with MS.
Others remain in limbo for years, wondering if they will ever get a
definite MS diagnosis. This is partly because there is no single
diagnostic test to establish a definite MS diagnosis, and also because
there are many diseases which manifest symptoms similar to MS. These are
called MS mimics.
WHY MIMICS MATTER
Familiarizing yourself with MS mimics and the ways in which they
compare to MS can demystify much of the diagnostic process. Sometimes,
the process of elimination is the only way to a MS diagnosis. Therefore,
the more you know about MS mimics, the quicker you and your doctor can
eliminate them as possibilities. Today, with MS specialists advocating
early, aggressive treatment, the sooner a MS diagnosis can be confirmed,
the better.
"If you are diagnosed with MS, you want to be sure that the diagnosis
is correct," states Dr. Jack Burks, Clinical Professor of Neurology at
the University of Nevada School of Medicine and senior editor of the
book Multiple Sclerosis: Diagnosis, Medical Management, and
Rehabilitation. "Certainly, other diseases can look like MS, but the
treatments are not the same."
AUTOIMMUNE DISEASES THAT MIMIC MS
Acute Disseminated Encephalomyelitis (ADEM) is a demyelinating,
neurological disease characterized by inflammation of the brain and
spinal cord. Symptoms may include headache, seizure, stiff neck, ataxia,
optic neuritis, vomiting, weight loss, lethargy, delirium, and
sometimes paralysis of a single limb or one side of the body.
ADEM differs from MS in that it is often clearly triggered by an
immunization, or viral infection. The most common cause is prior measles
infection, usually in children. ADEM runs a monophasic course, which
means that there is one episode.
Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE), is a chronic, inflammatory
disease that may affect the skin, joints, blood and kidneys. Symptoms
include achy, swollen joints, extreme fatigue, anemia, skin rash, sun or
light sensitivity, hair loss, seizure, and Raynaud's phenomenon, where
fingers turn white or blue in the cold.
Sometimes called the great imitator, lupus commonly displays symptoms
associated with another disease, such as MS. Lupus and MS can be
diagnosed simultaneously, although that is less common than being
diagnosed with one disease, and then later, diagnosed with the other.
An antinuclear antibody (ANA) test can help to confirm a lupus
diagnosis, but other diseases, including MS, can also produce positive
ANA results. In addition, even a person who has lupus will not always
produce positive results on this test. A urinalysis or kidney biopsy may
be performed to check for signs of possible kidney problems. MRI, CT
scan, echocardiography, x-rays, and other diagnostic criteria are also
used. Sometimes, MS lesions on the spinal cord can be a distinguishing
factor, or first-trimester miscarriages, which are quite common in women
with lupus, but not women with MS.
Sjögren's Syndrome is a chronic disease in which white blood cells
attack the moisture-producing glands. It is a systemic disease, which
means that it affects the entire body. Symptoms include dry eyes and
mouth, difficulty swallowing and speaking, fatigue, joint pain,
decreased sensation, and numbness. Sjögren's can plateau, worsen, or go
into remission, and some people will experience mild symptoms, while
others will be greatly debilitated.
Nerve conduction velocity (NCV) tests can be helpful in
differentiating between MS and Sjogren's because nerve damage in MS is
central, but nerve damage in Sjögren's is peripheral. However, this is
not always the case. Occasionally, Sjögren's affects the central nervous
system, causing cognitive impairment and spinal cord involvement.
"Some researchers believe that Sjögren's syndrome is somehow linked
to MS," Burks says. "But this opinion remains highly controversial."
Myasthenia Gravis (MG) is a disease in which weakness occurs when the
nerve impulse responsible for initiating movement fails to reach the
muscle cells. Individuals with MG have an increased risk of developing
other autoimmune diseases.
MG symptoms tend to fluctuate throughout the day, often worsening at
night. Droopy eyelids, facial weakness, impaired eye coordination,
weakness of the limbs, neck, shoulders, hips and trunk muscles are all
typical. Muscle fatigue is common, and heat, overexertion, or increased
stress can aggravate this symptom. MG can occur at any age, although
young women and older men are the most commonly affected. Those with MG
experience no loss or change in sensation and they don't normally
experience generalized fatigue. Instead, they experience localized
fatigue in overtired muscles.
"A very specific test for MG is a blood test for serum antibodies to
acetylcholine receptors," Burks explains. "Eighty percent of all
patients with MG will have abnormally elevated serum levels of these
antibodies."
Sarcoidosis typically appears between the ages of 20 and 40. Usually,
the disease appears briefly and heals naturally. However, between 20
and 30 percent of sarcoidosis patients are left with some permanent lung
damage, and in 10 to 15 percent of the patients, the disease can become
chronic. Symptoms include dry mouth, excessive thirst and fatigue, skin
rash, vision abnormalities, chronic arthritis, shortness of breath,
enlarged lymph glands, cough and fever. A chest x-ray is one of the most
helpful diagnostic tools.
INFECTIOUS DISEASES THAT MIMIC MS
Lyme disease (LD) is an infection caused by Borrelia burgdorferi, a
bacterium carried by deer ticks. Untreated, the bacterium travels
through the bloodstream, causing severe fatigue, a stiff, aching neck,
tingling or numbness in the extremities, and facial palsy. The primary
symptom is usually a rash that radiates from the tick bite. Diagnosis
should be made on the basis of symptoms and evidence of a tick bite, not
blood tests, which can often give false results if performed in the
first month after infection.
Those who live or work in residential areas surrounded by
tick-infested woods, or enjoy hiking, camping, fishing and hunting, or
live in endemic areas are at increased risk for this disease.
Human T-cell lymphotrophic virus-1 (HTLV-1) is associated with
progressive spinal cord dysfunction. Symptoms include spasticity,
partial paralysis of the lower limbs, bladder and bowel incontinence,
and impotence. HTLV-1 can be ruled out with a titer, which is a type of
elevated antibody test. "HTLV-1 affects the spinal cord and does appear
similar to primary progressive MS," Burks explains. "But HTLV-1
primarily occurs in the Caribbean, so it is important to ask about
travel to endemic areas. Besides the Caribbean, these areas include
Southern Japan and less commonly, the Pacific Coast of South America,
Equatorial Africa and the Southern United States. HTLV-1 is also common
among intravenous drug users."
Neurosyphilis, the advanced form of syphilis, can cause visual
problems, cognitive changes, and sensory or motor tract dysfunction. As
with HTLV-1, testing the production of antibodies can eliminate syphilis
and neurosyphilis from the list of possible diagnoses. "Neurosyphilis
is not as common as it once was," Dr. Burks explains. "This is because
syphilis, the forerunner of neurosyphilis, is so readily treatable
today."
VASCULAR DISEASES THAT MIMIC MS
Stroke symptoms include sudden trouble with vision in one or both
eyes, sudden trouble walking, dizziness, loss of coordination, sudden
severe headache, confusion, trouble speaking or understanding, sudden
nausea, fever, vomiting or loss of consciousness.
"Strokes can be caused by bleeding in the brain or by blood clots
that cut off the blood supply to an area of the brain," Burks explains.
"The result is that neurons in the brain die. Major strokes cause very
obvious losses in function and are unlikely to be confused with MS.
However, smaller strokes can produce changes or loss in function that
can look similar to a MS attack. Many people with MS have first been
misdiagnosed with stroke."
Central nervous system (CNS) Angitis, an inflammation of the blood
vessels of the brain, can produce headache, confusion, and other
neurologic deficits that slowly progress.
Dural Arteriovenous Fistulas are abnormal structures of blood vessels
along the spinal cord that deprive the spinal cord of blood, resulting
in weakness, bladder and bowel changes, and sensory symptoms, all of
which appear in a relapsing or progressive manner. MRI of the spinal
cord or spinal angiography may be required to confirm diagnosis.
Binswanger's is a cerebrovascular disease usually seen in older
patients with high blood pressure. Demyelination of the white matter
surrounding the brain, similar to white matter lesions seen in MS, can
appear with this disease.
OTHER MIMICS
Other diseases are occasionally confused with MS. These include
fibromyalgia and vitamin B12 deficiency, muscular dystrophy (MD),
amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS or Lou Gehrig's disease), migraine,
hypo-thyroidism, hypertension, Beçhets, Arnold-Chiari deformity, and
mitochondrial disorders, although your neurologist can usually rule them
out quite easily.
Fibromyalgia involves pain and fatigue of the muscles, ligaments and
tendons. Muscular pain can be shooting or throbbing. Burning, stiffness,
fatigue, face and head pain, cognitive impairment, numbness, tingling,
dizziness and impaired coordination are common. Changes in weather,
hormonal fluctuations, stress or depression can all contribute to
symptom flare-ups.
"Although fibromyalgia does mimic MS, it will not show up on an MRI
or even be observable at an exam," Burks says. "Fibromyalgia is very
non-specific."
Vitamin B12 deficiency may cause demyelination, numbness and tingling
of the hands and feet, fatigue, weakness, and in extreme cases, change
in mental status. "There is a theory that vitamin B12 can actually
produce more myelin, so people with MS may assume that they need more of
it," Burks says. "But B12 is only beneficial if you have a deficit to
begin with."
A FINAL WORD.
"While MS may have many mimics, a neurologist can usually make a
correct diagnosis early in the disease by taking a careful history,
doing a complete neurological exam, looking at the MRI, and sometimes,
evaluating the spinal fluid," Dr. Burks states. "If you are concerned
about your diagnosis, you can discuss your concerns with your
neurologist and possibly get referred for a second opinion from a MS
expert at a comprehensive MS center. The Multiple Sclerosis Foundation
can help you locate a MS center in your area."
(Last reviewed 7/2009)
Look
around the next time you venture out to the movies or the grocery
store, or any place crowds of people congregate. You don't need to be a
trained yoga teacher to recognize that most of the heads around you
don't seem to be screwed on quite right to their respective bodies.
Though in the West, we spend a lot of time "in our heads," ironically,
most of us don't know what to do with our heads—how to hold and move
them properly—not only in asanas but in our daily lives. We tend to
carry our heads to a greater or lesser degree forward of the spine, a
symptom of the widespread afflictions of stress and poor posture. The
ideal upright head is physically neutral, perched lightly atop the atlas
(the aptly named first cervical vertebra) and supported by the
underlying column of bones and minimal muscular effort in the back of
the neck and shoulders. Along with this bare-bones support, the head is
also sustained energetically by what I call the root of the neck. You
won't find this root in any anatomy book. Like the roots of the arms and
legs, the root of the neck is imaginary—but the image can be of immense
practical use and can have profound therapeutic benefits.
Did you know your food can affect your mood? What you eat and the
state of your digestive system can keep you healthy and happy or may
cause schizophrenia, depression, and developmental disorders.
Dr. Natasha Campbell-McBride's book, Gut and Psychology Syndrome,
shows how digestion can affect your mental health. With clear
explanations and helpful diagrams, she clearly shows how food can change
your mood, and more! While Dr Campbell McBride's dietary suggestions
follow the guidelines of the Specific Carbohydrate Diet, Donna Gates
recommends that EVERYONE read The Gut and Psychology Syndrome
today to learn valuable information that will enhance your
understanding of the connection between the brain in our gut and the
brain in our head!